|
Who Says You Can't Fight City Hall?
Mostly out of the public eye, and almost totally without preliminary
hearings, the three Republican dittoheads on the Federal Communications
Commission recently used their majority to approve an "update" of the rules
governing mass media ownership.
In so doing, they hoped to present an early Christmas gift to the fatcats in
communications and an undeserved finger to the viewing and reading masses.
Remarkably, Commissioner Kathleen Q. Abernathy, although she reportedly attended
none of the very few public hearings on the proposed new rules, confidently
proclaimed, "I am satisfied that we have the information and the input we need
to make a sound, judicially sustainable decision that will benefit the public
interest."
Judiciously sustainable it might well be, but unless the "public" to which she
referred was a small coterie of public figures in the Rupert Murdoch weight
class, the soundness of their decision was about on the level of a massive
investment in lottery tickets.
Specifically, what the FCC did was "update" the existing rules to permit, for
example, Viacom, Disney and AOL Time Warner to gobble up enough TV stations to
control nearly half of the national viewing audience, allow owners of "only" two
stations in large cities to acquire a third, and, in most cities, remove the
prohibition against cross-ownership of television stations and newspapers.
The net result, predictably, would be a sandstorm of mergers and acquisitions
which would leave far more information and entertainment outlets under the
control of far fewer owners. This would not, you may rest unassured, be in the
best interest of the public of which us-all are a part.
Those of us whose life span is admittedly approaching that of native moss can
recall when major cities, my native Philadelphia included, had at least two
morning and two evening newspapers daily, usually with divergent editorial
views. Today, by contrast, there is in my adopted Miami and elsewhere only one
morning bladder, the positions of which are about as flexible and unpredictable
as the average I-beam.
In my City-Of-Brotherly-Love boyhood, there was also a treasure-trove of local
radio/TV stations, with live talent, studio bands, original programming, and
genuine journalists behind the microphone (John Facenda, to name just one).
Typical today in most areas is single ownership of multiple stations, all so
highly automated that one boardmeister can operate them simultaneously, leaning
heavily on prerecorded cartridges, remote network feeds and push-button
technology.
Had it succeeded, the FCC's end-run around public scrutiny would have made a bad
situation worse, but it encountered that one monster most feared by bureaucrats,
influence peddlers and special interests - an informed and aroused electorate.
We of the politically unwashed masses are usually content to mutter into our
beers or teacups, wring our hands, curse our stars and silently suffer the
slings and arrows sent our way by the powers that be.
In this case, however, a reported million-plus of us stormed the bastions of the
F.C.C. and forded the moats surrounding our elected dulligates to Congress
behind a massive "hell, no!" banner. John McCain, chairman of the Senate
Commerce Committee described it as "sparking more interest than any issue I've
ever seen that wasn't organized by a huge lobby."
Score one for Vox Pop - the voice of the people!
Spurring that public outcry was an eclectic gaggle of groups including such
unlikely bedfellows as The National Rifle Association, National Organization for
Women, Consumers Union and the United States Conference of Catholics (that last
group knowing more than a little about the power of public protest).
As a result, a bill is slogging through the Senatorial swamp with
uncharacteristic speed which would not only spoil the media moguls' Christmas,
but would more than reverse the FCC proposals, actually loosening the noose on
our present information squeeze. Among other things, it would require some
shedding of holdings by the existing fatcats.
With a show of bi-partisan support that was totally lacking in the FCC proposal,
the reversing legislation breezed through McCain's Commerce Committee on a voice
vote, and appears heaven-bent for approval in the full Senate.
That's the good news, folks, and the proof that we, the "American people" so
often mentioned by politicians, need not be the sheep they hope we will be. City
Hall CAN be fought...and defeated!
Howsomever, as Yogi Berra reminded us, "the game ain't over until it's over,"
and it will be played out in the ball park of the House of Reprehensibles, where
the loins of the opposition are being girded by a coalition of lobbyists and
political contributors with sheaves of IOUs in hand.
It's the bottom of the ninth...time for the home team to step up to bat.
Be sure to let your designated hitter in the House know what you want!
|